Overview
Ubuntu recently decided to remove Gimp from the Live CD. And the community seems to not approve of this move. The Ubuntu team has there reasons and they definitely seem to be very legit. But why is the community so upset?
WhyThere can only be one reason why the Ubuntu Community is so upset, it's because they've had to live with all the ups and downs that Gimp has provided them through the years. The community has been there from the start. All they know how to use now is Gimp (this is a generalization).
Ubuntu has always tried to make the desktop environment so easy to use for the every day user. Those in the community that are outraged by this would not be considered every day user, they would be considered somewhat an experienced user. Try describing to an elderly person, maybe your grandparents how to use Gimp to crop that photo of you when you were a little kid. It might become a difficult task explaining the multi-paned window system (Gimp is changing this). But Gimp is what it is, it is an alternative to Photoshop. And people that actually fork out the cash to buy Photoshop are experienced users (or people who like to piss money away) that will use the software to either fulfill a hobby of theirs or for work.
Space. Ubuntu is trying to create a Live CD that will demonstrate all the great things that Ubuntu has to offer. And since Ubuntu has always been great at providing an option to be able to run on any machine via CD something as to go.
Now they could move up to a Live DVD, but that could cause issues for older machines that do not have a DVD drive. There are applications that are crucial that must be on the Live CD to demonstrate the power of the Operating System. Leaving out one application that only a select few will use does not seem that big of an issue.
What Most People Want...
Most users, especially in the work place don't use Gimp on a daily basis, unless they are Graphic Designer whom work for a Open Source shop (which I would consider lucky). The average user just browses the Internet, writes documents, prints maps, listens to music, and possibly plays games. Most users probably have a digital camera and whip it out every time their cat does something cute or at all special events that their child might get the chance to actually be a part in. Well these users don't need a application as robust as Gimp. These users just need a simple application that will allow them to tag their photos, maybe crop them, and post them to a web site so that the world might see (or send links to relatives to show off). A perfect example is Picasa, a simple photo editor that will allow the user to simply adjust small things in a photo.
Some arguments have been made as to; "Then why would the user need a video editor?". Well there are probably more users out there that would use a simple video editor to create home movies so they may share with their grand kids one day.
Alternative
There are tons of alternatives to this issue of Gimp being removed from Ubuntu. People should not be afraid that they are losing complete access to Gimp.
Roll Your Own
The great thing about Ubuntu is the ability to customize it to your standards. And with so many tools out there you can create your own CD. Probably even create your own live CD with Gimp already configured.
App Store
Ubuntu just released their own App Store. It is so simple now install applications that any user of any level can install Gimp. A couple clicks of the mouse and you are done.
Conclusion
Everyone just needs to relax. If this is the only issue that the Ubuntu Community has right now, the Ubuntu is doing a great job. There are alternatives to this issue as there always is.